I know the "tmi post" could be an unreliable source, but on there they claimed that Charlie and phil were a friends with benefits type thing, and phil was only messing around. then when he met dan, Charlie was jealous, and phil broke off that so called "toxic " relationship yadda yadda....captainspacecoat wrote:A relationship between people of any genders with an age gap of 22/16 definitely makes me feel uncomfortable, despite potential legality. However, I really don't think Phil and Charlie were ever in anything close to a relationship. They may have been kind of flirty on social media, but the fact that they only met up once suggests to me that it never went anywhere. There's no concrete evidence that they ever did anything sexual/romantic (Charlie has given conflicting information at different points, but I'm pretty sure I also remember him clarifying that they never dated?).
If anything, from an objective standpoint (and again, this is pure speculation so I may be completely on the wrong track) I would guess that Phil may have been the one to reject Charlie and clarify to him that he didn't want to be a relationship with him. Just based on the fact that they only met up once and then never again, and Charlie seemed to be pretty infatuated with Phil based on social media interactions (and he continued to be for years really), I would have thought that he would ideally have kept up a relationship with Phil and that makes me think Phil maybe did set him straight. Idk, I could be wrong, but I really don't get the vibe that Phil ever took advantage of Charlie.
I don't personally get the same vibes from Dan and Phil as they were not only of a legal age in terms of consent, but Dan was also legally an adult (18) and I think that does make a difference. That, coupled with the fact that they seemed to be at similar levels of maturity, means that I view it differently than I would if he was underage.
secretagentphan I'm pretty sure that's Phil's black 'Fairytale of New York' candle he showed in a liveshow, Dan has a similar one but it's white
Edit: or maybe it is the wax one? either way, i don't really see how it means anything
edit: lol I just checked some phan sources and it doesn't look like anything points to sexual relations between Charlie and phil. but lets just pretend its true for my earlier theory 2 pages ago
lol toxic like Britney Spears
pregnancy/motherhood in readings usually mean life, energy, birth of a new project or new ideas (it's not literal).
(and for that that t-shirt)
)
