IDB

captainspacecoat wrote:A relationship between people of any genders with an age gap of 22/16 definitely makes me feel uncomfortable, despite potential legality. However, I really don't think Phil and Charlie were ever in anything close to a relationship. They may have been kind of flirty on social media, but the fact that they only met up once suggests to me that it never went anywhere. There's no concrete evidence that they ever did anything sexual/romantic (Charlie has given conflicting information at different points, but I'm pretty sure I also remember him clarifying that they never dated?).

If anything, from an objective standpoint (and again, this is pure speculation so I may be completely on the wrong track) I would guess that Phil may have been the one to reject Charlie and clarify to him that he didn't want to be a relationship with him. Just based on the fact that they only met up once and then never again, and Charlie seemed to be pretty infatuated with Phil based on social media interactions (and he continued to be for years really), I would have thought that he would ideally have kept up a relationship with Phil and that makes me think Phil maybe did set him straight. Idk, I could be wrong, but I really don't get the vibe that Phil ever took advantage of Charlie.

I don't personally get the same vibes from Dan and Phil as they were not only of a legal age in terms of consent, but Dan was also legally an adult (18) and I think that does make a difference. That, coupled with the fact that they seemed to be at similar levels of maturity, means that I view it differently than I would if he was underage.

secretagentphan I'm pretty sure that's Phil's black 'Fairytale of New York' candle he showed in a liveshow, Dan has a similar one but it's white

Edit: or maybe it is the wax one? either way, i don't really see how it means anything

I know the "tmi post" could be an unreliable source, but on there they claimed that Charlie and phil were a friends with benefits type thing, and phil was only messing around. then when he met dan, Charlie was jealous, and phil broke off that so called "toxic " relationship yadda yadda....


edit: lol I just checked some phan sources and it doesn't look like anything points to sexual relations between Charlie and phil. but lets just pretend its true for my earlier theory 2 pages ago

lol toxic like Britney Spears

oqua wrote:

CallMeAyana wrote:...I know that the psychic thing is probably inaccurate, but I don't like Phil's reading about February.

Why not?

Compared to his other readings... It seems ominous (I mean, there's, like, three readings about pregnancy... I know I'm ridiculous). Maybe it's just me, anyways. (I really enjoyed it, though. I mean, I've been smiling all the way to school, which is creepy.)

sweetmm wrote:This video made me appreciate the reason why Phil ensure his video makes his viewers smile

I didnt think I was gonna cri today but

also that girl at 8:54, damn she been watching phil since the beginning..... 9 years honey???!!!!!!

Happy Birthday Phil!!

btw the banner is so cute guys

CallMeAyana wrote:

oqua wrote:

CallMeAyana wrote:...I know that the psychic thing is probably inaccurate, but I don't like Phil's reading about February.

Why not?

Compared to his other readings... It seems ominous (I mean, there's, like, three readings about pregnancy... I know I'm ridiculous). Maybe it's just me, anyways. (I really enjoyed it, though. I mean, I've been smiling all the way to school, which is creepy.)

...what is ominous about pregnancy? pregnancy/motherhood in readings usually mean life, energy, birth of a new project or new ideas (it's not literal).

Awwww so excited for Philly's birthday, hope he has a lovely day!

I thought it was a nice video, considering he talked about wanting to be really creative it wasn't the most inspiring thing I've seen him do from an idea perspective, but technically it was good and I always like to see him continuing to try hard with his videos and make them that little bit special or different than everyone else's bedroom vlogs. I am so very fond of his style and hope he never loses that. It's pretty rare on YouTube nowadays; now it's all "editing is just piecing together all these clips of me saying how much I loved these products despite not using them myself for the cha-ching!"

Happy birthday to Phil I love the banner.

MJ's video rating = but with some (and for that that t-shirt)

Timestamps: Predicting My Future
0:09—Did he really start his video with a photoshopped picture of his grandmother in sunglasses and a snazzy cap? (was that phil’s voice during the illuminati music?)
0:12—baby mention #1
0:47—phil does a f-ing adorable wave with his hand
1:17—Phil’s “whoo” noise makes life worth living
1:32—I really like his editing here, I’m always pretty impressed with his editing skills like sure they’re not super sophisticated but he does cute things like this that add to his narrative instead of just being thrown in there, & he’s talented timing wise when inserting sound effects (ex: 1:40)
2:05—I love how he doesn’t edit out his sneeze. reminds me of the liveshow where he “taught” everyone how to make hot coco…Especially b/c of this shitty camera quality
(also are those rubber ducks on top of the fridge and fan? )
2:53—I shouldn’t be so excited at the thought that he was most likely watching steven universe with dan while drinking that tea
3:21—Baby mention #2
3:30—phil mentioning his crotch should not seem revolutionar, yet here I am mildly surprised—pre-baking phil didn’t have sexual organs
3:37—I’m kinda put off by Phil’s shameless spon…it seems like he just forced it in there and like, he promos the gaming channel three times in this video why do you need to force-promo a video while in a video? And won’t think kinda be awkward when people are watching this video in the future? 4:15--
4:34—Deppy exchange = rehearsed (I’m so cynical today)
5:42—I wonder how many times Dan’s gonna help phil reach a “climax of inspiration” today
5:50—is this phil’s voice singing or just a generic sound bite? I’m thinking it’s phil’s voice
6:09—Phil talking about drinking on Christmas...party!Phil emerging like we were promised???
6:27—another gratuitous gamingmas mention :/
6:38—Phil, darling, when you’re sitting down you’re supposed to unbutton your suit jacket. rule one of fancy clothes etiquette.
Also drinking mention number 3 in less than 2 minutes has his channel become PG-13????????
7:17—baby mention #3 (prepare for the spike in mpreg fics )
8:37—“it’s in german!”
9:07 or 9:10 starts end-screen promo-ing, depending on how you look at it. he ends at 10:01, so he ends with around 50 seconds of straight self-promo
but It’s kind of respectable how he doesn’t even try to hide the fact that he forced the video to be exactly 10:01 minutes long—aka maximizing his sweet sweet revenue

me complaining…
I never usually criticize phil and I don’t want to seem overcritical now because I honestly did love this video, his personality really shines here. It’s just that if you are going to treat youtube as a job (which I understand) go ahead and promote your other channels, advertise a monthlong series you did, talk about a person you work with… but when it takes away from the content (aka the job) like I felt it did here, it seems to me disappointing.

Edit: LOVE the header

That's a pretty banner! I like that all recent critical comments on Phil's last video are a bit apologetic bc it's his birthday Fair enough. (Also I agree with those.)

This is completely random but if anyone's interested in seeing Dan and Phil's most liked and retweeted tweets, here they are:

Dan's most liked:
1) "finally @AmazingPhil exposed" (cereal)
2) #LoveIsLove (post-Orlando)
3) "ooh wowie six million subbydingdongs"
4) wholesome howell
5) pokémon go trainer cosplay
6) "ok why is it raining in australia if i wanted a depressing british experience i'd stare in the mirror and think about my regrets for an hour"

Dan's most retweeted:
1) wholesome howell
2) "finally @AmazingPhil exposed"
3) "a big HAPPY BIRTHDAY to everyone's favourite angel bean"
4) #LoveIsLove
5) "is it possible to live without 1/5 of your heart"
6) "apparently it's #NationalBestFriendDay fuck you @AmazingPhil"

Phil's most liked:
1) "Dan burnt his finger on a toaster lol"
2) Dan asleep on the plane
3) Amazingdanisnotasepticeye
4) "My Japan panda wish came true!"
5) "What am I even sitting next to right now"
6) Gas leak for four years

Phil's most retweeted:
1) Dan asleep on the plane
2) PINOF 7 is here
3) PINOF 8 is here
4) "Dan burnt his finger on a toaster lol"
5) "My Japan panda wish came true!"
6) #10YearsofAmazingPhil

If you want to see all of them, you can check them out on the website "favstar" -
Phil's most liked: http://favstar.fm/users/amazingphil/most_favorited
Phil's most retweeted: http://favstar.fm/users/amazingphil/most_retweeted
Dan's most liked: http://favstar.fm/users/danisnotonfire/most_favorited
Dan's most retweeted: http://favstar.fm/users/danisnotonfire/most_retweeted

Happy Birthday Phil!!!

I love the banner! Great work guys!!

Ooohhh cute banner. HBD PHIL! I am way too excited for Phil's birthday and I have no idea why. Who have I become? What have I become? But anyways I'm keeping my fingers crossed for cute pics/stories from this weekend and a cute hbd tweet from Dan today. I totally made this post just so I could see angel bean under my name

I loved Phil's new video. It made me smile super hard.

And Dan's tweet...omg....kill me. Bye.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY PHIL. I'm so excited to see what this day will bring.

My best friend and I work together and recently decided to request a day off together so we could hang out and she asked what day I wanted to do and I jokingly suggested today since it's Phil's birthday and that's the one she put...lmao. She wants to make him a cake. Fine by me.

Happy Birthday to the sweetest bean ever!
PJ posted this and it gave me major nostalgia!

This is from a few hours ago but cute I guess Martyn and Cornelia are also there on the IOM then?
Also I'm intrigued by the Fantastic Foursome interaction!

I'm anxiously awaiting Dan's tweet lol. C'mon Dan, don't disappoint us, we've been having such a good phan run. Honestly this past week has been one of the worst in my life for various reasons so Deppy being married has been one of the only things keeping me happy. Dan and Phil have the opportunity to make me full demon phannie after this birthday weekend, AND WE ALL DESERVE IT

secretagentphan wrote:I'm anxiously awaiting Dan's tweet lol. C'mon Dan, don't disappoint us, we've been having such a good phan run. Honestly this past week has been one of the worst in my life for various reasons so Deppy being married has been one of the only things keeping me happy. Dan and Phil have the opportunity to make me full demon phannie after this birthday weekend, AND WE ALL DESERVE IT

Honestly, the radio silence ony enhances my demon status. :twisted: They are obviously too busy celebrating Phil to address the commoners.

Happy, happy birthday to Philly!!! Now, get a dog!

Look at all of us fellow angel beans Nice job on the birthday theme to tptb

Philena wrote:

secretagentphan wrote:I'm anxiously awaiting Dan's tweet lol. C'mon Dan, don't disappoint us, we've been having such a good phan run. Honestly this past week has been one of the worst in my life for various reasons so Deppy being married has been one of the only things keeping me happy. Dan and Phil have the opportunity to make me full demon phannie after this birthday weekend, AND WE ALL DESERVE IT

Honestly, the radio silence ony enhances my demon status. :twisted: They are obviously too busy celebrating Phil to address the commoners.

Happy, happy birthday to Philly!!! Now, get a dog!

Look at all of us fellow angel beans Nice job on the birthday theme to tptb

Watch Dan do something simple like "Happy Birthday Phil" and leave it at that.

malday wrote:

I'm not crying there's a in my eye

malday wrote:

Obviously my 100th post it's going to be about how Danny loves Philly with his whole heart.

'EVERLASTING AS THE SUN' K I L L M E N O W

malday wrote:

"the light and warmth you bring to my our lives is as everlasting as the sun"
This ironically corny little shit.

hannah wrote:

malday wrote:

"the light and warmth you bring to my our lives is as everlasting as the sun"
This ironically corny little shit.

Literally the perfect balance of branding (as in you can tell it's for us to see) and thoughtful. It's lighthearted but sincere I hope our boys have a great day today
BTW nice name Hannah's unite

(Okay so to get the part nobody cares about out of the way: Hi! I'm new, lurked GG for an embarrassingly extended amount of time, found this place, liked it much more, caved and made an account. Do people still post these disclaimers? Idk but here I am.)

"the light and warmth you bring is as everlasting as the sun" That's disgustingly cute and corny and the perfect way for Dan to use his #ironic humour and deliver that sweet fanservice whilst also getting away being as sappy as he likes to Phil on Twitter. The best of both worlds!